From system failure to smart selection
“Houston, we have a problem.” In trucking, as in aerospace, fleets cannot delay action when system failures affect critical areas such as operations, maintenance, safety, or compliance.
Suppose your ELD and telematics system experiences an issue that forces drivers to revert to paper logs, risking hours-of-service violations. Meanwhile, dispatchers lose visibility into loads; safety teams miss critical events; billing and payroll slow; and vehicle maintenance issues go unnoticed.
If system failures disrupt your operations, you want a better ELD and telematics solution. However, replacing a platform is a significant decision. To justify the time, cost, and potential disruption, the investment must do more than solve immediate problems. Your evaluation process must demonstrate how a new platform will improve business conditions and deliver a clear return on investment.
Ideally, you will develop current- and future-state flowcharts that show how your processes will improve with new technology. However, like many fleets, you may lack the internal resources and budget to map these processes across every department and to analyze how each vendor’s ELD telematics platform addresses your current gaps.
This article explains how a structured discovery exercise can help you identify your true needs and evaluate telematics vendors more effectively. Let’s review what this process entails to determine whether you can handle it yourself or would benefit from outside assistance.
Start with your business processes
Capital investments are major decisions in the tight-margin trucking business. Fleet leaders must understand exactly what they are getting, with no surprises, when evaluating ELD telematics solutions.
Ideally, an experienced IT team or outside technology consultant leads your evaluation and selection process, gathering input from key stakeholders to determine which new platform best fits your business needs and improves outcomes.
Most fleets have small IT departments, or none, and lack budgets to hire project managers and consultants. In these cases, fleets can benefit from an ELD telematics provider with a consultative approach. Rather than presenting features and functions, such a vendor listens to your needs during a discovery meeting and draws on experience analyzing similar fleets’ business processes.
A consultative approach may include an on-site discovery visit to help the vendor better understand your drivers, operations, safety, compliance, and maintenance processes. A vendor’s experience meeting with fleets like yours helps the vendor ask the right questions to understand your needs.
Examine how work gets done
A discovery project is the foundation for evaluating telematics vendors. It requires gathering information and documenting how different end-user team members complete processes end to end.
Documenting the process flow in the following areas starts with asking questions about how end users do their jobs with the information a system provides, at every step, including when they encounter exceptions:
- Safety and compliance: Fleets typically have massive volumes of telematics and video event data on unsafe driving behaviors and compliance issues. By documenting how users manage this information, you’ll spot instances where they respond to alerts and critical events rather than use insights to proactively mitigate risk. Each instance is an opportunity to improve the process.
- Operations: Load planners, dispatchers, and billing clerks need accurate, real-time information. Yet they may encounter delays or inaccuracies in ETAs, delivery receipts, and other data and documents they need to execute loads, bill customers, and pay drivers.
- Maintenance: Fleets need to maximize uptime and availability while controlling vehicle costs. Documenting how mileage data, fuel efficiency, fault codes, and driver-vehicle inspection reports (DVIRs) are used will reveal process breakdowns that contribute to real-world problems.
- Driver workflow: What happens on the road mirrors what happens in the office. Gaps or inaccuracies in how drivers capture data or documents create back-office issues. Do your mobile workflows help drivers plan trips accurately and capture details to streamline customer service, payroll, and billing?
Dig deep and get a demo of your future state
Asking the right questions prompts end users to explain how they handle different scenarios. When the listener understands how an ELD and telematics platform should connect people and processes, they can ask more targeted questions to dig deeper into problem areas. For example, the interviewer could ask, “What happens if something goes wrong?” to determine whether users are following a standard operating procedure (SOP) for managing exceptions. You might also discover that users have workarounds or frequently encounter bottlenecks or roadblocks that add time and cost.
Once you have accurately mapped how your fleet works today, you can evaluate different systems based on how well they will move your current state toward a desired future state. The challenge is knowing what different systems can and can’t do to achieve that future state.
A live demonstration is valuable after you’ve established the future state you’re after. Instead of watching a generic product demo, ask each vendor to demonstrate your future state. For example, they could show a sample load or trip from your fleet moving from dispatchers to drivers and back to the office for billing and payroll.
A four-part checklist for a better evaluation
Fleet leaders gain value from working with a vendor that can professionally assess how their business operates, either by complementing their own discovery with a consultative approach or by conducting a full on-site discovery to map your processes and uncover issues that might otherwise go unnoticed.
A professional analysis of your processes, either from a staff member, consultant, or an experienced vendor, will help to:
Break tunnel vision. Individual departments often develop highly specific ways of working. For example, a safety team may be comfortable with a current vendor’s reporting tools and the relationship. Yet a solution that works well for one department can still create inefficiencies elsewhere.
Establish trust. A discovery analysis gives your fleet and the vendors you evaluate a chance to assess how each operates before implementation begins. If the fleet moves forward, both sides start with a shared understanding of processes, priorities, and responsibilities.
Set clear expectations. In‑depth exploration may reveal a need for a feature or capability that does not yet exist. In these situations, ask vendors to clearly distinguish what is available today, what they will develop, and what they are not committed to delivering. This transparency prevents surprises.
Calculate ROI. By flowcharting your processes, you can better evaluate how each vendor can deliver a future state that reduces costs, improves productivity, mitigates risk, and streamlines operations. At this point, you can apply time and dollar amounts based on your own operating and financial assumptions to estimate the potential ROI.
Evaluate the vendor, not just the technology
Discovery and evaluation should address more than process gaps; they should also identify opportunities to fix them with each vendor’s solution. A vendor with the expertise to analyze your processes should also explain how they’ll handle configuration, integrations, training, and support during and after implementation.
An ELD telematics platform’s flexibility matters. Some allow you to configure workflows yourself, such as adding arrival forms to a driver’s check-in process for pickups and deliveries. Additionally, ask a vendor how they handle complex connections, such as integrations with a TMS or third-party applications, and whether they support third-party applications on in-cab mobile devices.
Fleets should also evaluate any vendor based on how smoothly they can transition you to a new system. A vendor can significantly reduce the burden on your IT department and end users during implementation by giving you a head start with:
- Process mapping that shows how their technology will improve your business in critical areas such as driver workflows, operations, maintenance, safety, and compliance.
- Clear integration blueprints that outline how a vendor’s technical team will address gaps to ensure seamless integration of their telematics platform with your TMS and other third-party applications.
- Implementation and training support from dedicated resources with trucking expertise to help you use the system effectively.
- A single point of support so your employees won’t be passed from one agent to another when they have an issue. The person you speak with should own any problem you encounter.
Choose a partner who wants to understand your business
To evaluate ELD and telematics platforms effectively, fleets need to understand how they operate today—from driver workflows and load dispatching to safety and compliance, maintenance, and system integrations.
Once your processes are clearly mapped, technology is much easier to evaluate. Rather than comparing vendors primarily on features, fleet leaders can assess how each solution fits their workflows, where it can eliminate inefficiencies, and what implementation and ongoing support resources are available.
For fleets without extensive internal IT resources, a vendor with a formal discovery program and expert staff can help evaluate where you are now and where you could be. This expert help pays dividends whether you ultimately move forward with them or not. At the very least, you will know exactly how their system can, or cannot, fill gaps in your processes.
When evaluating telematics systems, look for a provider that can clearly demonstrate how their platform will meet your immediate needs and improve processes you didn’t realize could be improved. If the provider takes a consultative approach and has expert staff who care enough to spend time on the ground with fleets like yours, they will better understand your pain points, clarify your needs, and ultimately help you make the best decision.
Talk with ISAAC’s experts about where you are now, where you want to go, and how our ELD telematics platform can help you get there.
Frequently asked questions about choosing a telematics vendor
What should fleets look for in a telematics vendor?
When choosing a telematics vendor, fleets should look beyond individual features and functions and evaluate how the overall system will meet their requirements and support end-to-end processes across operations, safety, compliance, maintenance, and drivers’ daily workflows.
How can a fleet evaluate telematics software without a large IT department?
A fleet without a large IT department can evaluate telematics software by mapping its current processes through in-person discovery sessions with drivers and end users across operations, safety, and maintenance. Next, it should identify process gaps and define its system integration requirements. Finally, it should ask vendors to demonstrate how their solutions will fill these gaps and support the fleet’s defined future state.
What is the best way to compare telematics vendors?
The best way to compare telematics vendors is to look for those that care enough about the industry to invest in on-site discovery programs to understand how fleets like yours are struggling and how they can help. Any vendor worth your time should take a consultative approach and clearly explain, in detail, how their system will improve critical areas like driver workflow, dispatch, safety, and maintenance.
How can fleets transition smoothly when choosing a new ELD and telematics provider?
Fleets can transition smoothly to a new ELD and telematics provider by accurately mapping current and future-state processes for every department. They should also hold vendors accountable for helping them reach that future state by engaging the vendor’s technical team to establish clear goals and timelines for implementation, training, and support.
